5) Ethical Leadership and Sustainable HR Practices

Assessing the role of Leadership style in promoting ethical and sustainable practices in HRM

Introduction

The contemporary business world has seen a change in the leadership that used to be based on performance and profit maximization. The contemporary leaders are expected to be more ethical and show interest in being sustainable. The role of Human Resource Management (HRM) has taken precedence in enhancing ethical and sustainable practices in organizations as organizations deal with global issues, including climate change, inequality, and workforce welfare. Moral leadership has especially become a key driver that influences organizational values, employee conduct, and sustainability. This essay analyzes the direct impact of leadership style and especially ethical leadership in ethical and sustainable HR practices, and how the behavior of the leader, the organizational culture, and the results of strategic HRM relate and are reflected.

Getting to know Ethical Leadership.

Ethical leadership may be encapsulated as the exercise of normatively proper behavior at the individual, interpersonal, and promotion of the same behavior among the followers (Brown and Treviño, 2006). Ethical leaders are moral role models who focus on accountability, transparency, and fairness in making decisions. They are directed by the principles of justice, honesty, and respect for the stakeholders. Ethical leaders in HRM settings promote ethical behaviors that respect the rights of employees, create a sense of inclusiveness, and adhere to ethical guidelines.

                                In contrast to authoritarian or transactional styles of leadership, ethical leadership combines moral considerations in all the managerial functions. It integrates the transformational leadership concepts (inspiration and vision) with judgment of morality to provide employees with a model to follow. The ethical leaders not only affect the HR practices through policy but also determine the moral climate of the organization.

The Overview of Sustainable HR Practices.

Sustainable HRM is defined as HR practices and processes that make contributions to the long-term success of an organization and society, and still maintain human, social, and environmental resources. Ehnert (2009) also suggests that sustainable HRM transcends conventional HR practices as it entails incorporating the principles of sustainability into the recruitment, training, performance management, and employee engagement practices. It enhances fair work conditions, balance in work life, diversity and inclusion, unceasing learning, and risk-taking talent management.

                               The idea of sustainable HR practices is to make human resource policies consistent with the larger objectives of environmental sustainability, corporate social responsibility (CSR), and ethical governance. By embracing sustainable Hr practices, the leaders will establish a balance between the performance of the organization and employee welfare, making certain the sustainability of the workforce and the business.

(Solutions, 2024)

The impact of the Leadership Style on the Ethical and Sustainable HR practices.

The style of leadership greatly influences the design of the HRM policies, their implementation, and perception among people in an organization. The implications of the various leadership styles to the sustainability and ethics vary between transformational, transactional, autocratic and ethical leadership. Of them, ethical leadership is the most directly associated with sustainable HRM since it entails integrating moral logic and social accountability into the mainstream of organizational conduct.

1. Developing the Culture and Organizational Values.

Leaders are important to set the ethics of an organization. Ethical leaders foster concepts like fairness, respect, and integrity, which are instilled in the HR policies and operations of the day. An example of such includes ethical leadership that promotes openness in the recruitment of candidates, equality in employment, and promotions based on merit. This leads to an ethical culture where good ethical behaviors are rewarded and bad moral behaviors are discouraged. Through emulating ethical behavior, the leaders provide behavioral patterns that the employees are likely to follow. This type of modeling will minimize the misbehavior and will elevate the trust in the organization. The HR departments, in turn, are then given the mandate of enacting codes of conduct, ethics training, and reporting mechanisms that are in line with the values of the organization.

2. Fostering Workforce Health and Inequality.

The ethical orientation of a leader has a direct impact on the employee welfare of HRM. Ethical leaders understand the value that employees are human beings and not resources. The resultant policies are based on the belief in health and safety, work-life balance, and fair pay. To illustrate, an ethical leader will make sure that remuneration is fair and career advancements are made available to the employees, irrespective of gender, race, or culture. Psychologically safe workplaces are also considered sustainable HR practices with ethical leadership. Ethical leaders enable openness, allow feedback, and avoid exploitation and discrimination. Consequently, employees have increased job satisfaction, loyalty, and motivation- aspects that ensure ethical compliance in addition to organizational sustainability.

3. Incorporating the Environmental and Social Responsibility into HR.

Ethical leaders usually take a holistic view of sustainability and understand that HR policies should consider the environmental and social impacts. These leaders can embrace sustainability in their employee training and promote environmentally friendly activities like consuming less energy, eliminating paper usage, and embracing sustainable use of resources. The recruitment policies can focus on employees with sustainability values, and the performance reviews can contain sustainability-related objectives. In addition, ethical leaders promote CSR activities by engaging employees in community building, volunteering, and social awareness activities. These activities help not only in the strengthening of the reputation of the organization, but also in the feeling of purpose and belonging among the employees. 

4. Improving Transparency and Accountability.

The two ethical leadership and sustainable HRM are based on transparency and accountability. The ethical leaders make sure that HR practices are fair and present, like promotions, appraisals, and disciplinary measures, are made based on specific criteria. This minimizes favoritism, prejudice, as well as unethical activities in the place of work. Through open communication, ethical leaders can make employees speak up on matters relating to unethical behavior without fear of retaliation. These types of whistleblowing practices and ethical hotlines are some of the good examples of sustainable HR practices that flourish under ethical leadership. This will improve employee confidence and corporate credibility.

5. Long-term Strategic Impact

The type of leadership will either make HRM reactive in handling sustainability or be proactive. Long-term thinking is an aspect of ethical leaders, who realize that long-term success relies on people-centered management. They invest in training and development programs that create ethical cognizance and leadership potential in workers. This will preserve ethical culture even during a change of leadership. Moreover, when ethical leaders are in charge of an organization, there are higher chances that they have sustainable performance management systems that integrate financial targets with social and environmental performance. This combined strategy fortifies the resilience, flexibility, and relationship of the organization with stakeholders.

Difficulties in Adopting Sustainable and Ethical HR Practices.

Although these are the benefits, the integration of ethical leadership and sustainable HRM can be hindered by a number of challenges. To begin with, ethical concerns may be compromised by business pressures in the short run. Leaders can put profit goals above the welfare of employees or the environment. Second, there are differences in the perception of ethics and sustainability on the regional and industry levels due to cultural and contextual factors. Third, the absence of ethics and sustainability leadership training may lead to the inconsistent use of ethical standards.In order to address these issues, companies have to systematize ethics by means of robust governance structures, ongoing leadership training, and participation of stakeholders. Leadership selection, evaluation, and rewards systems should be instilled with ethical leadership to guarantee long-term influence. 

The HR in the Process of Bolstering Ethical Leadership.

Ethical leadership and sustainability can only be enhanced through HR departments. They will be able to incorporate ethical competencies in leadership development initiatives, use available ethical performance measures, and conduct ethical dialogue avenues. In addition, the HR professionals are moral agents and can be found ensuring that the HR policies protect human rights, equality, and sustainability. Ethical HR leaders are also able to work closely with the top management to streamline the HR strategy with the CSR and sustainability goals of the organization. This integration ensures a more integrated system in which leadership behavior, HR policies, and organizational goals complement each other.

                        A style of leadership is a determinant in the establishment of ethical and sustainable HRM practices. Fairness, integrity, and responsibility are some of the attributes of ethical leadership that build the environment of sustainable organizational performance. Ethical leaders can be used to influence all aspects of HRM, including recruitment and performance management, employee engagement, and well-being through ethical role modeling, openness of communication, and social and environmental values. Sustainable HR practices under ethical leadership will make sure that organizational development is moderated in terms of human dignity, equity, and ecological stewardship. Consequently, ethical leadership development is not just a management decision, but a strategic requirement of establishing solid, reliable, and sustainable organizations in the 21st century.

Connection with Transformational and Servant Leadership, Ethical Leadership, and Sustainable HR Practices.

Introduction

The contemporary business world puts organizations in a twofold dilemma of not only gaining a competitive advantage, but also upholding ethics and social accountability. Ethical leadership has become one of the major cornerstones of sustainable human resource (HR) practices, which guarantees that organizations promote fairness, transparency, and accountability in people management. Sustainable HR practices move beyond compliance, and the values of environmental, social, and governance (ESG) are incorporated into the fabric of workforce management. In this background, Transformational Leadership and Servant Leadership theories can serve as useful theories in the explanation of how ethical leaders can make people commit themselves to long-term sustainability objectives. To promote sustainable HR practice that enhances worker welfare, organizational resilience, and social accountability, this essay discusses how ethical leadership is related to these two theories.

Ethical Leadership and its application in the sustainable HR practices.

The basis of ethical leadership is based on moral values and being able to show integrity, honesty, and fairness in decision making (Brown and Treviño 2006). Ethical leaders exemplify proper behavior, convey ethical values, and enforce ethical behavior through accountability. Ethical leadership in HR is important in promoting equal recruitment, open performance management, and accountable talent development. Green HRM and diversity and inclusion, employee well-being programs, and socially responsible practices are all sustainable HR practices, and in all these cases, the leader must focus on the ethical aspects rather than the financial benefits that might be achieved in the short term.

                      Ethical leadership influences trust and psychological safety cultures required to have sustainable HR systems. Leaders who lead ethically will result in higher employee imitation as a way of promoting organizational citizenship behavior (OCB) and adherence levels to sustainability goals. As an illustration, fair compensation, responsible downsizing, and ethical supply chain management are examples that indicate the correspondence between ethical leadership and sustainable HRM. Ethical leadership is, therefore, the moral compass that can assist HR professionals in engaging in practices that uphold human dignity to enhance the long-term legitimacy of an organization.

Transformational Leadership and Ethical Leadership Synergy.

The attributes of transformational leadership were proposed by Burns (1978) and then developed by Bass (1985), whose main focus was on the capacity of the leader to inspire and motivate the followers to new heights of performance and moral purpose. It contains four fundamental dimensions such as idealized influence, inspirational motivation, intellectual stimulation, and individualized consideration. These aspects are the direct complement of ethical leadership and strengthen sustainable HR practices. Having idealized influence, transformational leaders serve as moral exemplars who are full of integrity and religious fear. To its part, the employees gain trust and admiration and generate ethical conduct at all levels of the organization. Inspirational motivation helps employees to imbue their own goals with the long-term vision of the organization and to foster the spirit of teamwork. The intellectual stimulation also requires the followers to think and creatively innovate in the green HRM, eco-efficiency and social responsibility areas. Lastly, personalized attention is consistent with HR's value of building people, embracing everyone, and diversity.

                      When transformational leadership is incorporated into ethical leadership, sustainability is made a central organizational principle and not a marginal program. As an example, visionary and value-driven leaders can incorporate sustainability measures in HR practices such as training, rewards, and performance appraisal. By so doing, they can convert ethical ideals into HR practices that make them viable in the long term. Transformational leadership is therefore an ethical catalyst- converting values into long-term behavioural and systems change in organisations.

Servant Leadership: Service-based Ethics and Empowerment.

Whereas transformational leadership aims at vision and inspiration, servant leadership revolves around humility, service, and the development of other people. Servant leadership was introduced by Greenleaf (1970), and it is based on the idea that the leader is there to serve the followers. Such a philosophy is intrinsically interconnected with ethical leadership and sustainable HR practices, as it advocates empathy, stewardship, and community building. Servant leaders consider the well-being and development of employees as their priority, which is the main focus of sustainable HR management. Servant leaders enable employees to feel appreciated and respected by instilling a culture of care, trust, and empowerment. Servant leadership enhances ethical Hr practices like the promotion of mental health, work-life balance, and fair opportunity of advancement. This would push leaders to think about the long-term consequences of HR decisions to people and communities instead of just concentrating on short-term profitability.

                         Moreover, servant leadership boosts employee participation and ethical devotion. When employees realize that their leaders care about their well-being, they return the favor by being loyal and offering discretionary effort, which are the main aspects of sustainable performance. Coming with a servant-based approach to leadership, therefore, produces a virtuous cycle: ethical performance inspires trust, trust leads to increased involvement, and involvement leads to long-term results.

Combining Ethical, Transformational, and Servant Leadership to Sustainable HR.

The ethical, transformational, and servant leadership intersectional form the holistic approach to sustainable HR practices. Ethical leadership offers the moral basis, transformational leadership gives the visionary motivation, and servant leadership offers the human-centered care. The two then foster a balanced attitude that does not put performance excellence and moral responsibility in opposition. As an illustration, an ethical leader will be fair and transparent when formulating a sustainable HR strategy, a transformational leader will direct HR to focus on the organizational sustainability vision, and a servant leader will focus on the well-being and growth of its employees. This kind of integration assists organizations in practicing sustainability, such as green recruitment, ethical performance appraisal as well as inclusive training programs. Furthermore, this leadership triad promotes lifelong learning, communication, and innovation; all that is needed to adapt to global sustainability challenges.

                         Practically, examples of such a synergy in leadership are organizations like Patagonia and Unilever. Their leaders have shown their ethical standards by practicing fair labor, a transformational vision by having a mission focused on sustainability, and servant leadership by empowering their employees and engaging with the community. These practical examples demonstrate that ethics-based and sustainability leadership can create long-term value to both human beings and the earth.

Issues and Consequences.

Although it has benefits, there are numerous problems with ethical and sustainable HR practices. Leaders are expected to strike an equilibrium between the expectations of stakeholders, regulatory compliance, and profitability without sacrificing moral righteousness. Multicultural differences and the complexity of the global supply chain can also be a barrier to the uniformity of ethical behavior. Transformational and servant leaders, on the other hand, are in a good position to overcome such dilemmas because they bring about moral reasoning and open communication in the organization.

                       It would mean that the HR professionals have to switch to strategic and values-driven processes, as opposed to transactional ones. Ethics, sustainability, and social responsibility are some of the core competencies that need to be included in the leadership development programs. Besides, integrating ethical leadership practices within performance appraisal and succession planning guarantees the sustainability of HR practices regarding leadership generation.

 CONCLUSION

The influence of the leadership style on ethical and sustainable HR practices is both deep in terms of the way the organizations handle their people, but also in terms of determining their purpose and their contribution to society in the long run. Leadership is the moral and strategic guiding light of the organization and has an impact on the HR policies, ethical standards, and the wider sustainability agenda. Ethical leadership is one of the other leadership styles that may be considered as the cornerstone of sustainable HRM since it incorporates the approach of fairness, transparency, and accountability in all facets of people management. The ethical leaders encourage practices that are founded on integrity, like equitable hiring, fair compensation, and ethical career development, and through this, they develop a culture of trust and ethical conduct.

                      Transformational leadership builds on this ethical base by motivating the employees to internalize the values of sustainability and tie their personal development to the long-term vision of the organization. Transformational leaders stimulate the intellect and provide personalized attention that encourages innovation in sustainable HR strategies, including green training, inclusive development programmes, and socially-responsible performance systems. In the same manner, servant leadership will supplement these initiatives by promoting human well-being and empowerment. Servant leaders promote psychologically safe, caring, and fair work environments where employees feel admired and personally driven to work in ways that would lead to organizational sustainability objectives.

                                Together, these types of leadership combine to form a synergistic model in which ethics, vision, and service come together to form resilient and people-oriented organizations. They make sure that sustainability is not a side agenda but an ingrained corporate culture that is displayed in HR practices and decision-making. With the growing issues of globalization, social inequality, and environmental degradation facing organizations, it would be necessary to develop leaders with ethical, transformational, and servant qualities. This kind of leadership not only promotes employee engagement and organizational citizenship behavior, but it also makes the organization viable in the long term, credible, and morally legitimate in the rapidly changing world.

REFERENCES RELATED TO THE ASSIGNMENT

1. Bass, B.M. (1985). Leadership and Performance Beyond Expectations. New York: Free Press.
2. Burns, J.M. (1978). Leadership. New York: Harper & Row.
3. Brown, M.E. and Treviño, L.K. (2006) ‘Ethical leadership: A review and future directions’, The Leadership Quarterly, 17(6), pp. 595–616.
4. Ehnert, I. (2009). Sustainable Human Resource Management: A Conceptual and Exploratory Analysis from a Paradox Perspective. Heidelberg: Springer.
5. Greenleaf, R.K. (1970). The Servant as Leader. Indiana: Greenleaf Center for Servant Leadership.
6. Cameron, K. (2011). Responsible Leadership: A Relational Approach. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
7. Maak, T. and Pless, N.M. (2006) ‘Responsible leadership in a stakeholder society’, Journal of Business Ethics, 66(1), pp. 99–115.
8. Freeman, R.E. (1984). Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach. Boston: Pitman.
9. Yukl, G. (2013). Leadership in Organizations. 8th edn. Harlow: Pearson.
10. Northouse, P.G. (2022). Leadership: Theory and Practice. 9th edn. London: Sage.
11. Paillé, P., Chen, Y., Boiral, O. and Jin, J. (2020) ‘The impact of ethical leadership on employee environmental behaviour’, Journal of Business Ethics, 163(1), pp. 1–17.
12. Jamali, D., Safieddine, A. and Rabbath, M. (2008) ‘CSR and leadership’, Journal of Business Ethics, 82(3), pp. 213–231.
13. Stahl, G., Brewster, C., Collings, D. and Hajro, A. (2020) ‘Enhancing the role of HRM in CSR’, Human Resource Management Review, 30(4), pp. 1–12.
14. Renwick, D., Redman, T. and Maguire, S. (2013) ‘Green HRM: A review’, International Journal of Management Reviews, 15(1), pp. 1–14.
15. Brieger, S. and De Cremer, D. (2020) ‘Ethical leadership and CSR’, Journal of Management Studies, 57(2), pp. 281–309.
16. Osland, J., Li, M. and Wang, Y. (2014) ‘The leadership challenge in global organizations’, Organizational Dynamics, 43(3), pp. 169–178.
17. Walumbwa, F.O., Mayer, D.M., Wang, P. and Workman, K. (2011) ‘Linking ethical leadership to employee performance’, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 115(2), pp. 204–213.
18. Meyer, J.P. and Allen, N.J. (1991) ‘A three-component model of commitment’, Human Resource Management Review, 1(1), pp. 61–89.
19. Blau, P. (1964). Exchange and Power in Social Life. New York: Wiley.
20. Kramar, R. (2014) ‘Beyond strategic HRM’, The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 25(8), pp. 1069–1089.
21. Thom, N. and Zaugg, R.J. (2004) ‘Sustainable HRM’, in Losekoot, E. (ed.) Future Challenges in HRM. Geneva: ILO.
22. Guerci, M. and Carollo, L. (2016) ‘A paradox view of sustainable HRM’, Journal of Business Ethics, 138(3), pp. 505–523.
23. Van Dierendonck, D. (2011) ‘Servant leadership: A review and synthesis’, Journal of Management, 37(4), pp. 1228–1261.
24. Podsakoff, P.M., MacKenzie, S.B., Moorman, R.H. and Fetter, R. (1990) ‘Transformational leader behaviours and outcomes’, Leadership Quarterly, 1(2), pp. 107–142.
25. Cohen, E., Taylor, S. and Muller-Camen, M. (2012) ‘HRM’s role in sustainability’, International Journal of Human Resource Management, 23(10), pp. 212–246.